Need a Fast, Family-Friendly Ride to Replace My BMW X1? What Should I Buy?

Understanding Shon’s Needs

Shon, who resides in Boulder, Colorado, is looking to replace his aging BMW X1. His ideal vehicle should be quick, comfortable for his kids, and capable of hauling some cargo. He prefers something that isn't a crossover and wants something somewhat unique. The challenge lies in finding a car that fits all these criteria while staying within a budget of around $40,000.

Key Requirements

Shon is looking for a car that meets the following specifications:

Near 5 seconds from 0 to 60 mph
All-wheel drive (AWD)
Reasonable back seat space
Ability to haul a non-zero amount of stuff
Trackability without breaking the bank
A minor plus: ability to sleep in the back

He also emphasizes the need for a fun-to-drive experience, practicality for family use, and a unique design that stands out from the usual SUVs and CUVs.

Expert Recommendations

Tom McParland – You Asked For Unique

Tom McParland suggests considering a wagon as it offers a blend of practicality and style. He points out that while the classic Caddy CTS-V wagon would be ideal, it's not available at the desired price point. Instead, he recommends the Jaguar XF-S Estate. This model features a supercharged V6 engine with 380 horsepower, stylish design, and luxury features. A 2020 example with 60,000 miles is priced at $30,000, leaving room for future maintenance costs. However, he acknowledges the potential risks associated with owning a used Jaguar.

Andy Kalmowitz – The Wagon You Deserve

Andy Kalmowitz proposes the Mercedes-Benz E63 S AMG Wagon as the perfect fit for Shon. This high-performance wagon boasts a hand-built twin-turbocharged 5.5-liter AMG V8 engine producing 577 horsepower and 590 pound-feet of torque. It can accelerate from 0 to 60 mph in just 3.4 seconds, making it ideal for both daily driving and occasional track days. A 2014 model listed on AutoTrader is available for $35,000, which is slightly over Shon’s budget. However, Andy encourages Shon to consider negotiating or seeking a deal.

Collin Woodard – Ride In A Little Red Wagon

Collin Woodard suggests a more affordable alternative in the form of a BMW 330i xDrive Sports Wagon. This model, finished in Melbourne Red Metallic, is priced at $33,971 and has only 22,407 miles on the odometer. While it may not be as quick as Shon hoped, it offers 255 horsepower and 295 pound-feet of torque, making it suitable for Colorado’s altitude. It also includes heated front seats, which will be useful during colder months. Although not as unique as some other options, it provides a balance between performance and practicality.

Final Thoughts

Shon’s search for a unique, high-performance wagon presents several viable options. Each expert recommendation offers a different approach, balancing power, practicality, and uniqueness. Whether opting for a luxury model like the Jaguar XF-S Estate or a high-performance option like the Mercedes-Benz E63 S AMG Wagon, there are choices that align with Shon’s needs and budget. By carefully evaluating each option, Shon can find a vehicle that meets his requirements and enhances his driving experience.